According to an old, fairly well-known joke, a clock that is stopped is better than one that loses time—say, five seconds every hour—because the stopped clock is right twice every day, whereas the slow one is right only once every year. Mike Hockney, I take it, would not find this funny at all. On the contrary, he would think it obvious that the stopped clock was better.
“The scientific method,” Hockney argues in his book The Mathematical Universe (2014), “produces successful theories; it does not produce true theories.”(650-652)[1]. And success, in the absence of truth, Hockney seems to believe is little better than no success at all:
Scientific materialism is absurdly incoherent. (653)
Scientific materialism is a joke. It’s now much closer to Berkeleyan empiricist idealism than it is to any kind of materialism.(676-677).
Scientists are living in a fantasy world if they think they will ever explain reality.(911)
Science doesn’t know what anything is. It’s just a set of measurements with labels attached.(915-916).
Scientists – wedded to empiricism rather than rationalism – have evolved beyond the Abrahamists but are still seriously retarded.(1043-1044).
All scientists are inherently irrational.(1062)
Scientists, locked into their sensory worldview…lack the imaginationand intuition to be truly intelligent. It’s up to the elite – ontological mathematicians – to put these scientific apes in their place.(1306-1308).
Science is the quasi-religious worship of sensory experience, and the rejection of rational unobservables.(1802-1803).
Science’s understanding of the fundamental ground of reality is insane.(4856).
Science is anti-rationalism. Science is as bad and deluded as the other great enemy of rationalism: religious faith.(5187-5188)
The tragedy is that science is now run by fools.(5399-5400)
To many scientists and their supporters, statements like these are sure to inflame. The successful theories of science, after all, have provided us with all of our modern technology, including medicine, communications, transportation, and so on. Hockney’s alternative view, which as we shall see is based on reason and particularly mathematics, could not by itself have given us the computers and the internet that allow him to disseminate this view. It would not have allowed us to eradicate many diseases and to extend the average lifespan of members of our species. It would not have given us rapid access to almost any place on earth, as well as allowed us to explore outer space.
Nor is science just about utility, helping us survive and prosper. It has also delivered a fairly coherent picture of our world. As E.O. Wilson described in Consilience (1998), the different areas of science—physics, chemistry, biology, behavior—fit together to describe how primordial atoms evolved into molecules; molecules evolved into cells; cells evolved into organisms; and organisms evolved behavior, including our own. The result is a history, beginning billions of years ago and culminating in modern human societies. For the most part, this story hangs together remarkably well.
So what is Hockney’s problem? He is concerned with ultimate questions, and particularly one that science not only has not yet solved, but which many thinkers, probably including some scientists, think science may never solve: how did the universe begin, i.e., how did something arise from nothing? The mainstream scientific view is that the universe came into existence with the Big Bang, about fourteen billion years ago, which created its fundamental constituents, matter, space and time.
Here is the problem with that view, according to Hockney:
What and where were the laws of physics before the physical universe came into being? What laws were controlling the Big Bang as it happened? What laws caused it in the first place? Whatever caused and controlled the Big Bang must, of necessity, have preceded the Big Bang, yet scientists openly say that space, time and matter did not exist prior to the Big Bang. In which case, there’s nothing left within the empiricist, materialist paradigm to account for how the Big Bang happened…
No scientist has ever plausibly explained where scientific laws come from, how they interact with mutable, material things and how they exist at all.(565-573).
I think this is a fair criticism. Certainly scientists themselves are aware of this problem. They are also aware of other rather embarrassing deficits if not down-right contradictions in their theories, also pointed out by Hockney, such as the paradoxes and multiple interpretations associated with quantum mechanics, the inability to reconcile this theory with other theories such as relativity into a single grand theory, the lack of any way to test the claims of some ideas such as string theory, and so on. Science is clearly an ongoing, incompleted project that features not just gaps in its knowledge, but implications that sometimes make no sense to any of us.
The question is, is there a better alternative? For example, is there a solution to the problem of something from nothing? Hockney and his fellow Illuminati, as they call themselves, think there is, and that it lies in making reason, particularly mathematics, the primary source of our knowledge, rather than sensory observations:
only mathematics delivers seamless truth since it’s based on analytic a priori truths and not on contingent, ad hoc hypotheses subjected to unreliable experimental verification.(653-654).
Human reason – within the strict context of mathematics – is always right and always superior to empiricism.(682-683).
Only mathematics allows absolute knowledge of existence to be attained. (3969-3970)
You simply cannot rely on your senses if you want definitive answers to existence. If you want answers, you must use your reason, not your senses. Mathematics is the ultimate subject of reason. It has no connection whatsoever with the senses. The whole of mathematics can be worked out without ever looking at the world.(4515-4518)
Science, to be plausible when it comes to the ultimate questions, must be based on rationalist mathematics and not on the empiricist scientific method that is incapable of addressing infallible, absolute truths.(4640-4642).
In The Mathematical Universe, Hockney lays out his case in support of this. I found this treatise creative, interesting, provocative and certainly worth the read. It definitely stimulated a lot of thinking on my part, and I wouldn’t hesitate to recommend it to scientists, philosophers and anyone else deeply interested in the fundamental questions of our existence. Nevertheless, I think it has some fairly serious flaws, which I will discuss here.
A Total Zero
According to Illuminism, as Hockney’s view is called, the world begins with monads, zero-dimensional points that have always existed and are so structured that they contain, in effect, all of mathematics:
Illuminism begins with the simplest possible thing – a single mathematical point. This is the monad, the basic unit of existence. Being unextended, it conforms with Descartes’ definition of a thinking mind…it contains all the numbers between zero and infinity in all directions, signs and orientations. These numbers exist in anextremely precise way, guaranteed to produce a net result of nothing so that the point is ultimately defined by the number zero, the inverse of which is infinity.(415-422).
Those with some background in philosophy will immediately see in the concept of monads the influence of Leibniz, whom Hockney greatly respects. In fact, Hockney traces the Illuminist movement back to Pythagoras, the great Greek philosopher and mathematician, through Liebniz and on to the present day, describing it as a mostly ignored view that has been handed down from generation to generation by a small group of adherents. Though the central underlying principle has remained constant—mathematically-based reason is the key to understanding ourselves and our world—the details of the view have been modified somewhat over the generations. Thus Hockney’s version of monads is somewhat different from Leibniz’s, and in particular, it is that last descriptive statement that Hockney claims resolves the something from nothing problem. As he goes on to expound:
In order for zero to be the inevitable and inescapable net result of the combination of infinite numbers, all of the numbers must conform with the most powerful analytic formula in the whole of mathematics – Euler’s Formula, the great jewel of mathematics: eix = cos x + i sin x…
What’s so remarkable about Euler’s Formula is that it produces perfect balance between negative and positive numbers, between real and imaginary numbers and between zero and infinity. No element is privileged over any other. The net ontological effect of theformula is zero (since the circle’s negative half perfectly cancels its positive half), yet this is an “infinite” zero, a structured “nothing” that goes on forever!…
In order to include all possible ontological numbers, it’s necessary to introduce a more generalized form of Euler’s Formula:
A e i( fx + ö) = A cos (fx + ö) + i A sin (fx + ö)
where A is amplitude, f is frequency and ö = the phase angle (phase shift). In the frequency domain, the three elements necessary to specify a wave are amplitude, frequency and phase, so this generalized formula allows all possible waves to be accommodated. (426-450)
Bringing in waves is essential to Hockney’s view of how monads create the phenomenal world, which I will discuss later. But for now, let’s return to the something from nothing issue.
A “simple” point is therefore nothing of the kind. It’s an infinite information system, based on a superposition of infinite waves of every conceivable permutation, all of which put together produce a sum of zero (total and infallible balancing to zero).
Simply by defining a wave as the mathematical basis and definition of energy, a point is transformed into a repository of infinite, balanced energy. And bear in mind that this energy is necessarily eternal. Euler’s circle never stops spinning. Nothing can ever halt it – because ultimately there’s nothing there! An Euler circle is simply an ingeniously ordered and structured nothingness that can never perish. It’s always rotating and can never stop. Energy is just eternal motion.(451-458)
The foundational, uncaused causes of reality must be mathematical and they must have the property of being “nothing” since nothing is the compulsory rational ground state of existence. Mathematics has the ultimate rational trick up its sleeve – because “nothing” can also be something. It’s precisely because something and nothing can be equated (via an equation as simple as, for example, 2 – 1 – 1 = 0) that we are all here at all; that anything is here.(579-582).
What is “nothing”? It’s categorically not “non-existence”. Nothing is actually something. Something is mathematically structured nothingness. The generalised Euler Formula is exactly the miraculous mathematical instrument that allows nothing to be structured.(996-998)
So the Illuminist solution to the problem of “something from nothing” is to equate the two. Nothing, properly understood, is “ingeniously ordered and structured”, creating “an infinite information system, based on a superposition of infinite waves of every conceivable permutation, all of which put together produce a sum of zero”.
It’s not Sufficient to be Sufficient
In assessing this view, the first thing to emphasize is that this is simply a postulate, no different in principle from the assumption of universal scientific laws. How does Hockney know that this Euler-based system exists? The short answer is that he believes this is the only reasonable scenario:
Since it has only one element, the Euler universe is in best accord with Occam’sRazor. There’s nothing outside it. It explains everything. It leaves no gaps, hence obeys Leibniz’s principle of continuity. It’s the basis of Leibniz’s principle of sufficient reason, and of all causality. It enshrines all of Plato’s immutable, eternal laws (considered mathematically).(4556-4560)
Leibniz’s principle of sufficient reason, which says everything happens for a reason, is especially important to Hockney, who uses it in two ways: 1) to demonstrate that the scientific worldview does not follow this principle, in that no sufficient reason can be given for why there are particular scientific laws rather than others, why that which is observed through the senses should be regarded as real, and so on; and 2) to show that a sufficient reason can be given for the existence of the monads:
Via [Euler’s] formula, existence can be maintained at its necessary groundstate of zero (nothing), while always being something. (Any non-zero resultant cosmic energy is forbidden. There is no sufficient reason why the cosmos should have any arbitrary energy, and why such an energy should be above the ground state.)(441-444)
If one monad can exist with no net energy, what sufficient reason could prevent the existence of others, also with zero net energy? In fact, what could prevent the existence of infinite such “nothings”?(465-467)
The first law of thermodynamics (stating that energy can be neither created nor destroyed) is, rationally, a statement that the energy of the universe is always zero (because there could never be a sufficient reason for the energy to be greater than zero, and if the energy of the universe is always zero then it automatically follows that there can’t be any more or less of it).(588-591)
I think Hockney is at his best here, arguing against the apparent arbitrariness of the conventional scientific view of energy. Another, even better, example of this arbitrariness is found in the fundamental constants or parameters of the universe, which have to be set within very narrow limits for the universe to exist. No one understands why this is the case, and the fact that this is so upsetting to most scientists and other theorists is basically a validation of Leibniz’s principle. We believe there should be a reason for why things are the way they are. Einstein famously objected to the notion of a universe based on a roll of the dice.
Comments 292
Pingback: writeessay
Pingback: best canadian mail order pharmacies
Pingback: where can i buy levitra in uk
Pingback: cialis orders paypal paid
Pingback: pharmacy online viagra
Pingback: cialis for sale
Pingback: when will there be a generic cialis
Pingback: viagra scams on the internet
Pingback: senior viagra erections
Pingback: buy cialis now
Pingback: order original cialis online
Pingback: buy cialis cheap canada
Pingback: celebrex without persciption
Pingback: cialis without prescriptions canada
Pingback: generic cialis canadian
Pingback: cialis without presciption in usa
Pingback: canada cialis online
Pingback: how to stop cymbalta 20mg
Pingback: can i buy cialis in toronto
Pingback: cialis online daily
Pingback: buy cialis now
Pingback: buy cialis in miami
Pingback: buy cialis philippines
Pingback: sophia viagra no makeup
Pingback: cialis 20mg low price
Pingback: buy cialis now
Pingback: real viagra sex
Pingback: cialis professional
Pingback: jodi west viagra
Pingback: online pharmacy viagra
Pingback: cialis for sale
Pingback: levitra 20 mg
Pingback: discount viagra
Pingback: cialis cost
Pingback: incest viagra
Pingback: cialis otc
Pingback: viagra patent
Pingback: how much is viagra
Pingback: natural viagra for men
Pingback: cialis reviews by men
Pingback: viagra or cialis
Pingback: coupons for viagra
Pingback: viagra and blindness report 2017
Pingback: viagra sex party
Pingback: generic viagra without the prescription
Pingback: is viagra federally funded
Pingback: viagra commercial girl
Pingback: viagra model kathy king nude
Pingback: girl on female viagra
Pingback: viagra time to work
Pingback: couple cialis
Pingback: best viagra retailer
Pingback: otc viagra 2018
Pingback: sildenafil precio walmart
Pingback: viagra online donde comprar
Pingback: 100mg cialis for sale
Pingback: sildenafil 50 mg cost
Pingback: fish mox vs amoxicillin
Pingback: amoxicillin dosage for sinus infection
Pingback: azithromycin tablet
Pingback: celecoxib 200 mg capsule
Pingback: does keflex contain penicillin
Pingback: shell fish allergy and cephalexin
Pingback: cymbalta overdose
Pingback: buy viagra worldwide
Pingback: cialis actress australia
Pingback: viagra 50 coupon
Pingback: otc cialis 2018
Pingback: mom help son viagra problem jody west
Pingback: buy cialis online mexico
Pingback: buy tadalafil0 with pay pal
Pingback: where can i buy without a prescription
Pingback: cheapest retin a
Pingback: payday loan yes newark
Pingback: woman on viagra commercial
Pingback: 20mg for sale
Pingback: cialis bestellen
Pingback: köpä cialis
Pingback: buy ativan in pakistan
Pingback: buy cialis toronto
Pingback: canadian pharmacy east bay largo fl
Pingback: fake cialis side effects
Pingback: sending prescription drugs through mail
Pingback: does rx pharmacy coupons work
Pingback: trial pack cialis viagra levitro
Pingback: 20mg cialis daily
Pingback: viagra insurance
Pingback: tadalafil generic date
Pingback: women viagra pills
Pingback: generic cialis cheap
Pingback: citrate sildenafil
Pingback: neurontin dosage
Pingback: clonidine dosing for anxiety
Pingback: finasteride uses
Pingback: carvedilol moa
Pingback: metronidazole gel
Pingback: cialis 40mg generic
Pingback: sildenafil 100 mg
Pingback: levitra dose
Pingback: acyclovir cream 50mg
Pingback: omnicef
Pingback: tadalafil liquid review
Pingback: tadalafil 5mg tablets price
Pingback: levitra drugstore
Pingback: levitra over counter
Pingback: naltrexone medication pdf
Pingback: valacyclovir hcl 1gm tablet
Pingback: tizanidine medication classification
Pingback: tadalafil price walmart
Pingback: cipro antibiotic wiki
Pingback: generic cialis reviews
Pingback: cialis forum
Pingback: viagra and blood pressure
Pingback: bernie sanders canada drugs
Pingback: taking viagra and cialis together
Pingback: fucking on viagra
Pingback: the drug store pharmacy columbus ohio
Pingback: pharmacy technician in canada
Pingback: regcialist.com
Pingback: how to make natural viagra with immediate effect!
Pingback: losartan potassium hydrochlorothiazide side effects
Pingback: amlodipine what is it used for
Pingback: is lipitor a blood thinner
Pingback: phentermine and prozac
Pingback: how long can you safely take prilosec
Pingback: side effects of quetiapine 200 mg
Pingback: zoloft and tylenol
Pingback: boost mobile cards at walgreens
Pingback: escitalopram come in an elixir
Pingback: enalapril hydrochlorothiazide
Pingback: best time to take atorvastatin 40 mg
Pingback: lexapro withdrawal symptoms list
Pingback: duloxetine patient assistance program
Pingback: 1
Pingback: amox clav 875 for uti
Pingback: order propecia online india
Pingback: buy prednisone 20mg online
Pingback: tadalafil black
Pingback: ivermectin cas
Pingback: cialis 5mg uk
Pingback: 1 ivermectin
Pingback: buy stromectol online paypal
Pingback: ivermectin side effects
Pingback: cost of zithramax at cvs
Pingback: ivermectin pour on for goats
Pingback: ivermectin side effects dogs
Pingback: generic name for ventolin
Pingback: ivermectin pediatric dose
Pingback: petsmart ivermectin
Pingback: ivermectin dose for humans
Pingback: agri mectin ivermectin
Pingback: buy zithromax liquid online
Pingback: exercising while on lisinopril
Pingback: dapoxetine sildenafil review
Pingback: ivermectina 6mg
Pingback: cialis rxlist
Pingback: cheap clomid
Pingback: azithromycin for chlamydia over the counter
Pingback: ivermectin uses
Pingback: what parasites does ivermectin kill in humans
Pingback: azithromycin over the counter usa
Pingback: viagra 50mg price canada
Pingback: sildenafil pills from mexico
Pingback: pharmacies in canada shipping to usa
Pingback: amoxicillin pneumonia
Pingback: furosemide generic
Pingback: drug neurontin 20 mg
Pingback: quineprox 30
Pingback: prednisone pill 20 mg
Pingback: dapoxetine 30mg 1mg
Pingback: modafinil drug
Pingback: stromectol ebay
Pingback: chloroquine and hydroxychloroquine for sale
Pingback: ventolin prices
Pingback: zithromax purchase
Pingback: buy gabapentin uk
Pingback: otc stromectol for sale
Pingback: prednisone 54
Pingback: avana online
Pingback: cialis half life
Pingback: buy ivermectin nz
Pingback: generic tadalafil 10mg
Pingback: substitute for cialis
Pingback: viagra sales usa
Pingback: woman viagra over the counter
Pingback: ivermectin lotion for lice
Pingback: cialis patent expired
Pingback: azithromycin antibiotic class
Pingback: buy viagra cheap
Pingback: what is more effective
Pingback: viagra no script
Pingback: what is cialis taken for
Pingback: female viagra prank
Pingback: viagra essential oil
Pingback: viagra blood pressure
Pingback: stromectol tablets 3 mg
Pingback: generic cialis 5mg
Pingback: online clomid
Pingback: molnupiravir france
Pingback: lumigan dosage
Pingback: nolvadex sale
Pingback: zanaflex sleep
Pingback: zanaflex 40 mg
Pingback: Anonymous
Pingback: lilly baricitinib
Pingback: do you have to have a prescription for sildenafil?
Pingback: Anonymous
Pingback: Anonymous
Pingback: ivermectin tablets
Pingback: ivermectin buy
Pingback: where to purchase ivermectin
Pingback: ignition casino update
Pingback: where can i get ivermectin
Pingback: ivermectin tablets for humans
Pingback: order prednisone 20mg for sale
Pingback: generic cialis singapore
Pingback: tadalafil walgreens
Pingback: ivermectin oral
Pingback: stromectol over the counter
Pingback: cheap genuine viagra uk
Pingback: tadalafila
Pingback: natural viagra for men
Pingback: use of ivermectin
Pingback: tadalafil dosage
Pingback: buy cialis usa pharmacy
Pingback: tadalafil 5mg
Pingback: sildenafil tablets for sale
Pingback: tadalafil online
Pingback: roman tadalafil
Pingback: ivermectin 1 topical cream
Pingback: sildenafil pills online purchase
Pingback: generic sildenafil tablets
Pingback: cialis without a doctor prescription
Pingback: when will cialis be generic
Pingback: tadalafil prescription cost
Pingback: buy cialis online in india
Pingback: how to order prednisone online
Pingback: prednisone 20mg for eczema
Pingback: molnupiravir fact sheet for patients
Pingback: cialis online prescription usa
Pingback: cialis over the counter singapore
Pingback: where to buy cialis in australia
Pingback: ivermectin solubility
Pingback: prednisone side effects in women
Pingback: how long does viagra last
Pingback: buy tadalafil online
Pingback: $100 no deposit usa casinos
Pingback: cialis online
Pingback: stromectol pills
Pingback: ivermectin paste for humans
Pingback: usa casinos no deposit free welcome bonus
Pingback: cialis cost 20mg
Pingback: cost for generic viagra
Pingback: cialis dosis
Pingback: ivermectin dosierung
Pingback: cialis from canada no prescription
Pingback: uttar pradesh ivermectin
Pingback: how to get cialis prescription online
Pingback: stromectol coronavirus
Pingback: ciprofloxacin convert
Pingback: ivermectin cream 5
Pingback: azithromycin strength
Pingback: zithromax iv
Pingback: generic cialis tadalafil
Pingback: cephalexin dogs
Pingback: azithromycin sibo
Pingback: cephalexin other
Pingback: ivermectin 3mg
Pingback: furosemide 40 mg tablet uk
Pingback: buy cheap lasix without prescription
Pingback: ivermectin gel
Pingback: ivermectin for horses
Pingback: tadalafil and dapoxetine
Pingback: ivermectin 4000 mcg
Pingback: ivermectin protocol
Pingback: ivermectin for covid
Pingback: stromectol ivermectinst
Pingback: luckylandslots.com sign in
Pingback: ivermectin 8000
Pingback: stromectol to buy
Pingback: ivermectin tablet price
Pingback: ivermectin cream 1%
Pingback: ivermectin 4
Pingback: ivermectin pills
Pingback: ivermectin lotion price
Pingback: ivermectin 4 tablets price
Pingback: tadalafil cialis
Pingback: order ivermectin for humans
Pingback: ivermectin lotion
Pingback: ivermectin japan
Pingback: ivermectine usa
Pingback: ivermectin structure